Thread
:
Not happy with "The staff are happy" OR "The staff is happy"
View Single Post
#
25
Posted to microsoft.public.word.newusers,microsoft.public.word.spelling.grammar
Graham Mayor
external usenet poster
Posts: 19,312
Not happy with "The staff are happy" OR "The staff is happy"
Can be and often is, but I don't believe it was ever correct. I guess this
is just another case of evolving usage.
--
Graham Mayor - Word MVP
My web site
www.gmayor.com
Word MVP web site
http://word.mvps.org
Herb Tyson [MVP] wrote:
Depends on where you are. In the UK, staff can be considered a
collective noun, much as corporate entities, and often is considered
plural.
"gordo" wrote in message
...
Staff is a singular noun. Staff is agreement with the verb "is". If
it was a plural noun, such as staffs, then "staffs are happy" is in
agreement. I think.
Gordo
"Mari Broman Olsen" Mari Broman
wrote in message
news
Here's what I see on Word 2007
Staff is happy. [Correctly not flagged]
The staff are happy. [Correctly flagged]
The staff is happy. [Correctly not flagged]
A staff is happy. [Correctly not flagged]
What's the issue?
"Bill Davy" wrote:
In fact, the grammar checker seems to have green twiddlyitis with
the following:
The staff are happy. "staff are" have twiddles (suggests "staff
is" but see
below)
Staff are happy. "staff are" have twiddles (suggests "Staff is" or
"Staffs
are"
Staff is happy. "Staff" has twiddles (suggests "staffs").
The staff is happy. "Staff" has twiddles (suggests "staffs" but
see above).
A staff is happy. "A staff" has twiddles (suggests "Staffs")
Is it fixable? How?
Word 2003 SP2.
Reply With Quote
Graham Mayor
View Public Profile
Find all posts by Graham Mayor