Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
Posted to microsoft.public.word.docmanagement
|
|||
|
|||
"Don't hyphen" option in the Paragraph menu
This is my suggestion about clarity of Word's user-interface.
The Paragraph/"Don't hyphen" option in Word is somewhat hard to realize because it is negatively phrased. Unchecked it means that the user chose not to not hyphenate, which simply means hyphanate. In general, I think it's better not to create negative attributes having binary values and that all attribute should state positively, whatever the default value is. This remark is also valid for program variables by the way :-)) In this particular case, this option would be clearer if it simply stated "Hyphenate"... For compatibility, simply create a new property which yields the opposite of the already existing one... -- Stefano Gatto ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...ocmanagemen t |
#2
Posted to microsoft.public.word.docmanagement
|
|||
|
|||
"Don't hyphen" option in the Paragraph menu
In fact, I think it is a good thing that the option is called "Don't
hyphenate," because you use it to *prevent* text from being automatically hyphenated. Imagine the confusion if the option said "Hyphenate" and was checked by default, when you actually turn on hyphenation via Tools | Language | Hyphenation. -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... This is my suggestion about clarity of Word's user-interface. The Paragraph/"Don't hyphen" option in Word is somewhat hard to realize because it is negatively phrased. Unchecked it means that the user chose not to not hyphenate, which simply means hyphanate. In general, I think it's better not to create negative attributes having binary values and that all attribute should state positively, whatever the default value is. This remark is also valid for program variables by the way :-)) In this particular case, this option would be clearer if it simply stated "Hyphenate"... For compatibility, simply create a new property which yields the opposite of the already existing one... -- Stefano Gatto ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...ocmanagemen t |
#3
Posted to microsoft.public.word.docmanagement
|
|||
|
|||
"Don't hyphen" option in the Paragraph menu
I am sorry but I don't see where would be the confusion exactly. I was simply
talking about the phrasing of the check box... Instead of saying "Don't Hyphenate" it should say "Hyphenate" and show the opposite value compared to now, regardless of the default value (which I doubt any default value exists per sé, the actual "default" value is the one of the paragraph in the normal.dot or the paragraph inheriting from it...). Again, it's a pure user-interface suggestion, nothing else should change (even VBA's "ParagraphFormat.Hyphenation" remains the same). -- Stefano Gatto "Stefan Blom" wrote: In fact, I think it is a good thing that the option is called "Don't hyphenate," because you use it to *prevent* text from being automatically hyphenated. Imagine the confusion if the option said "Hyphenate" and was checked by default, when you actually turn on hyphenation via Tools | Language | Hyphenation. -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... This is my suggestion about clarity of Word's user-interface. The Paragraph/"Don't hyphenate" option in Word is somewhat hard to realize because it is negatively phrased. Unchecked it means that the user chose not to not hyphenate, which simply means hyphanate. In general, I think it's better not to create negative attributes having binary values and that all attribute should state positively, whatever the default value is. This remark is also valid for program variables by the way :-)) In this particular case, this option would be clearer if it simply stated "Hyphenate"... For compatibility, simply create a new property which yields the opposite of the already existing one... -- Stefano Gatto |
#4
Posted to microsoft.public.word.docmanagement
|
|||
|
|||
"Don't hyphen" option in the Paragraph menu
You are right that no default value exists for "Don't hyphenate"
beyond the setting of a particular paragraph style (this is true for any character and paragraph settings in Word). My point is that two steps are required for hyphenation to be enabled: you must be typing in a paragraph that doesn't have "Don't hyphenate" enabled, and you must be typing in a document with "Automatically hyphenate document" enabled in the Hyphenation dialog box. In other words, the Paragraph setting defines an *exception* from the hyphenation setting on the document level. If it was called "Hyphenate," it wouldn't be clear that hyphenation requires an extra step, namely, visiting the Hyphenation dialog box. How about this for a compromise: Call the option "Allow hyphenation in this paragraph"? -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... I am sorry but I don't see where would be the confusion exactly. I was simply talking about the phrasing of the check box... Instead of saying "Don't Hyphenate" it should say "Hyphenate" and show the opposite value compared to now, regardless of the default value (which I doubt any default value exists per sé, the actual "default" value is the one of the paragraph in the normal.dot or the paragraph inheriting from it...). Again, it's a pure user-interface suggestion, nothing else should change (even VBA's "ParagraphFormat.Hyphenation" remains the same). -- Stefano Gatto "Stefan Blom" wrote: In fact, I think it is a good thing that the option is called "Don't hyphenate," because you use it to *prevent* text from being automatically hyphenated. Imagine the confusion if the option said "Hyphenate" and was checked by default, when you actually turn on hyphenation via Tools | Language | Hyphenation. -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... This is my suggestion about clarity of Word's user-interface. The Paragraph/"Don't hyphenate" option in Word is somewhat hard to realize because it is negatively phrased. Unchecked it means that the user chose not to not hyphenate, which simply means hyphanate. In general, I think it's better not to create negative attributes having binary values and that all attribute should state positively, whatever the default value is. This remark is also valid for program variables by the way :-)) In this particular case, this option would be clearer if it simply stated "Hyphenate"... For compatibility, simply create a new property which yields the opposite of the already existing one... -- Stefano Gatto |
#5
Posted to microsoft.public.word.docmanagement
|
|||
|
|||
"Don't hyphen" option in the Paragraph menu
Yes, I like very much your compromise and accept it!
My point is not to use negative sentences for check boxes ever (in any other application not just Word), so your proposal perfectly satisfies my concern. My first proposal to use the wording "Hyphenate" was done without being in light of what you explained below, so definitely yours is more appropriate. -- Thank you for your insight. Stefano Gatto "Stefan Blom" wrote: You are right that no default value exists for "Don't hyphenate" beyond the setting of a particular paragraph style (this is true for any character and paragraph settings in Word). My point is that two steps are required for hyphenation to be enabled: you must be typing in a paragraph that doesn't have "Don't hyphenate" enabled, and you must be typing in a document with "Automatically hyphenate document" enabled in the Hyphenation dialog box. In other words, the Paragraph setting defines an *exception* from the hyphenation setting on the document level. If it was called "Hyphenate," it wouldn't be clear that hyphenation requires an extra step, namely, visiting the Hyphenation dialog box. How about this for a compromise: Call the option "Allow hyphenation in this paragraph"? -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... I am sorry but I don't see where would be the confusion exactly. I was simply talking about the phrasing of the check box... Instead of saying "Don't Hyphenate" it should say "Hyphenate" and show the opposite value compared to now, regardless of the default value (which I doubt any default value exists per sé, the actual "default" value is the one of the paragraph in the normal.dot or the paragraph inheriting from it...). Again, it's a pure user-interface suggestion, nothing else should change (even VBA's "ParagraphFormat.Hyphenation" remains the same). -- Stefano Gatto "Stefan Blom" wrote: In fact, I think it is a good thing that the option is called "Don't hyphenate," because you use it to *prevent* text from being automatically hyphenated. Imagine the confusion if the option said "Hyphenate" and was checked by default, when you actually turn on hyphenation via Tools | Language | Hyphenation. -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... This is my suggestion about clarity of Word's user-interface. The Paragraph/"Don't hyphenate" option in Word is somewhat hard to realize because it is negatively phrased. Unchecked it means that the user chose not to not hyphenate, which simply means hyphanate. In general, I think it's better not to create negative attributes having binary values and that all attribute should state positively, whatever the default value is. This remark is also valid for program variables by the way :-)) In this particular case, this option would be clearer if it simply stated "Hyphenate"... For compatibility, simply create a new property which yields the opposite of the already existing one... -- Stefano Gatto |
#6
Posted to microsoft.public.word.docmanagement
|
|||
|
|||
"Don't hyphen" option in the Paragraph menu
There are many negative statements in the Compatibility Options, but that
reflects the fact that often features added to a new version have to be turned off in previous ones. -- Suzanne S. Barnhill Microsoft MVP (Word) Words into Type Fairhope, Alabama USA Word MVP FAQ site: http://word.mvps.org Email cannot be acknowledged; please post all follow-ups to the newsgroup so all may benefit. "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... Yes, I like very much your compromise and accept it! My point is not to use negative sentences for check boxes ever (in any other application not just Word), so your proposal perfectly satisfies my concern. My first proposal to use the wording "Hyphenate" was done without being in light of what you explained below, so definitely yours is more appropriate. -- Thank you for your insight. Stefano Gatto "Stefan Blom" wrote: You are right that no default value exists for "Don't hyphenate" beyond the setting of a particular paragraph style (this is true for any character and paragraph settings in Word). My point is that two steps are required for hyphenation to be enabled: you must be typing in a paragraph that doesn't have "Don't hyphenate" enabled, and you must be typing in a document with "Automatically hyphenate document" enabled in the Hyphenation dialog box. In other words, the Paragraph setting defines an *exception* from the hyphenation setting on the document level. If it was called "Hyphenate," it wouldn't be clear that hyphenation requires an extra step, namely, visiting the Hyphenation dialog box. How about this for a compromise: Call the option "Allow hyphenation in this paragraph"? -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... I am sorry but I don't see where would be the confusion exactly. I was simply talking about the phrasing of the check box... Instead of saying "Don't Hyphenate" it should say "Hyphenate" and show the opposite value compared to now, regardless of the default value (which I doubt any default value exists per sé, the actual "default" value is the one of the paragraph in the normal.dot or the paragraph inheriting from it...). Again, it's a pure user-interface suggestion, nothing else should change (even VBA's "ParagraphFormat.Hyphenation" remains the same). -- Stefano Gatto "Stefan Blom" wrote: In fact, I think it is a good thing that the option is called "Don't hyphenate," because you use it to *prevent* text from being automatically hyphenated. Imagine the confusion if the option said "Hyphenate" and was checked by default, when you actually turn on hyphenation via Tools | Language | Hyphenation. -- Stefan Blom Microsoft Word MVP "Stefano Gatto" wrote in message ... This is my suggestion about clarity of Word's user-interface. The Paragraph/"Don't hyphenate" option in Word is somewhat hard to realize because it is negatively phrased. Unchecked it means that the user chose not to not hyphenate, which simply means hyphanate. In general, I think it's better not to create negative attributes having binary values and that all attribute should state positively, whatever the default value is. This remark is also valid for program variables by the way :-)) In this particular case, this option would be clearer if it simply stated "Hyphenate"... For compatibility, simply create a new property which yields the opposite of the already existing one... -- Stefano Gatto |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Word paragraphs should have a "Keep with previous" format option | Page Layout | |||
Mail Merge option missing from Tools menu | Mailmerge | |||
Bullets and numbering not an option on format menu in Word | Microsoft Word Help | |||
Where is the menu option for underling trailing spaces | Microsoft Word Help | |||
Mail merge option shows up several times under the "tools" menu. . | Mailmerge |