Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Status of 'Disable Features' Issues
Hi all,
Word 2002 replaced the old Word 2000 'Optimize for Word 97' option with the new 'Disable Features Introduced After' option, which brought some issues I documented nearly two years ago in the following post: http://groups-beta.google.com/group/...57a3e1fc8a3dcd (Search dejanews under 'Odd Behavior in Word XP Involving Disable Features' if above link misbehaves. Or try my name... My original post was March 28, 2003) Basically, what I found was that under Word 2002 the Disable Features checkbox would spring to checked during document saves, both interactively (intermittently) and under VBA/automation (consistently). This would cause documents with Word 2000 features, such as nested tables, to be downgraded to Word 97 format even though the user had taken no action to request or configure that. There were also some odd interactions between the old .OptimizeForWord97 and new ..DisableFeatures document properties. This is just the nutshell - the cite above has all the details. About a year ago MS acknowledged the problem in kb article: http://support.microsoft.com/default...b;en-us;832349 though that cite still lists the problem as unresolved. Now fast forward: Having just (belatedly) acquired Word 2003 I'm seeing that the issue may have been fixed or at least papered over - in fact, I'm having trouble programmatically forcing documents down to Word 97 features (not something I'm at all wanting to do btw , leading me to suspect/hope that MS may have taken some emergency or interim action in Word 2003 or it's SP's. I'm on 11.5604.5606 w/no SP's listed. Does anyone on the group have personal knowledge of the bug and it's current status, and whether that status changed between Word 2002 and 2003 versions? Anyone had trouble with Word 2003 nuking Word 2000+ features such as nested tables, especially in COM automated document management applications? TIA, David McBride |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Steve,
Gotta admit I'm a bit confused - did you read my post, or this a sort of automated reply? My post deals with Word incorrectly saving documents with the older Word 97 feature set - nuking post-97 features such as nested tables. I demo the bug with new documents being saved for the first time; there's no opening of documents where a 'pre-load pass' would come into play. I experienced the bug first under Word 2000, and am trying to verify that the bug has different manifestations under Word 2003. Was it this subject that your reply was referencing? Thanks, David McBride |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
G'day ,
yes Steve Hudson - Word Heretic steve from wordheretic.com (Email replies require payment) Without prejudice reckoned: Steve, Gotta admit I'm a bit confused - did you read my post, or this a sort of automated reply? My post deals with Word incorrectly saving documents with the older Word 97 feature set - nuking post-97 features such as nested tables. I demo the bug with new documents being saved for the first time; there's no opening of documents where a 'pre-load pass' would come into play. I experienced the bug first under Word 2000, and am trying to verify that the bug has different manifestations under Word 2003. Was it this subject that your reply was referencing? Thanks, David McBride |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
G'day ,
Word 2003 makes more dramatic changes to the underlying BFF than the other versions. It aggressively tries to order the document properly. This massively helps reduce document corruption. All versions of Word have compatibility settings for previous versions. (Tools Options) This also causes some aggressive restructuring of the file. These details are NOT readily provided by Microsoft, thus I cannot give you specific information, only this general information. That is why I sympathize with your predicament - I often (monthly minimum) find myself in the same bind on similar issues. Essentially, there is an awful lot goes on behind the scenes that us more technical users want to know more about so we can attempt to control out productions. This info is not readily available. Steve Hudson - Word Heretic steve from wordheretic.com (Email replies require payment) Without prejudice reckoned: Steve, Gotta admit I'm a bit confused - did you read my post, or this a sort of automated reply? My post deals with Word incorrectly saving documents with the older Word 97 feature set - nuking post-97 features such as nested tables. I demo the bug with new documents being saved for the first time; there's no opening of documents where a 'pre-load pass' would come into play. I experienced the bug first under Word 2000, and am trying to verify that the bug has different manifestations under Word 2003. Was it this subject that your reply was referencing? Thanks, David McBride |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Essentially,
there is an awful lot goes on behind the scenes that us more technical users want to know more about so we can attempt to control out productions. This info is not readily available. Amen to that... What's interesting about my issue is just how damn simple it should be to fix. Basically, somewhere in the Tools | Options code someone made a dumb error, probably in coordinating the new 'downgrade to version' options and properties with the older but similar controls that were Word97-specific. Two years have gone by, and another user who's been impacted to no end by this bug says MS told him that the underlying code is such a mess that it probably won't be fixed until whatever replaces Office 2003. Jeez. I do think I see some change though - it appears that MS patched it just a bit to force saves to happen with features enabled. In fact, with Word 2003 the bug appears to be the reverse of it's Word 2000 manifestation - I can't get Word to save with features disabled even by setting the appropriate properties. This would be a classic sign of a stopgap kluge. I'm just hoping, and hoping to verify, that indeed it's that, and not some difference in testbed environments that's giving me misleading results. Arghhh, David McBride |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
In fact, with Word 2003 the bug appears to be the
reverse of it's Word 2000 manifestation Correcting myself - above should read 'it's Word 2002 manifestation' Word 2000 worked perfect in this regard. David McBride |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
G'day ,
Just had a thought reading your reply. From Word 2k on, Word is forward compatible. That is, if it reads a BFF tag it doesn't understand, it keeps it intact to travel with the document, but ignores it otherwise. This means you should be able to read Word 2003 native documents in Word2k. It is possibly this 'feature' has given rise to the downgrade scenario presented. Steve Hudson - Word Heretic steve from wordheretic.com (Email replies require payment) Without prejudice reckoned: Essentially, there is an awful lot goes on behind the scenes that us more technical users want to know more about so we can attempt to control out productions. This info is not readily available. Amen to that... What's interesting about my issue is just how damn simple it should be to fix. Basically, somewhere in the Tools | Options code someone made a dumb error, probably in coordinating the new 'downgrade to version' options and properties with the older but similar controls that were Word97-specific. Two years have gone by, and another user who's been impacted to no end by this bug says MS told him that the underlying code is such a mess that it probably won't be fixed until whatever replaces Office 2003. Jeez. I do think I see some change though - it appears that MS patched it just a bit to force saves to happen with features enabled. In fact, with Word 2003 the bug appears to be the reverse of it's Word 2000 manifestation - I can't get Word to save with features disabled even by setting the appropriate properties. This would be a classic sign of a stopgap kluge. I'm just hoping, and hoping to verify, that indeed it's that, and not some difference in testbed environments that's giving me misleading results. Arghhh, David McBride |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Include the XML features in all copies of MS Word. I bought Stude. | Microsoft Word Help |